1930 - 1959
9 Mystic Valley League Titles
1 Middlesex League Title
3 State Championship Titles
1930
Mystic Valley League Title
9-0-0 Undefeated
Coach Harold Poole
Captain Arthur Hannigan
The first undefeated Melrose team in years had 9 successive wins and, according to the Melrose Log, had only 14 points scored against them all season.
1933
Mystic Valley League Title
Tied for 1st
Coach Harold Poole
Captain Wayne Parman
The 1934 team finished the season sharing the Mystic Valley League title when"severely handicapped by injuries, the team showed a fighting spirit which enabled it to beat heavier and more experienced teams."
1939
Mystic Valley League Title
Perfect Mystic Valley Record
Coach Harold Poole
Captain Howard "Jupe" Virgin
After a slow start they ended the season undefeated in the Mystic Valley League including 5 straight wins and tying Malden where Melrose was described as "outplaying their opponent in every sense of the word."
1942
Mystic Valley League Title
Class B State Champions
Coaches Dave Gavin/Kenneth Norris
Captains Billy McNamara &
Ed Cahoon
Undefeated Mystic Valley League Champions and Class B Football Champions whose "will to win" spirit overtook the league. The Melrose Log describes their "front wall" having "all the appearance of a college line boasting several 200 pounders."
1946
Class A State Championship
Coach Dick Gavin
Captain Ralph Loveys
According to the Melrose Log, the 1946 team came through a tough season by taking the Class A Championship, and also described the team as young with a hard-driving line and a light, fit backfield to do the job.
1931
Mystic Valley League Title
7-0-2
Coach Harold Poole
Captain Earl Ellsworth
After graduating all but 3 lettermen, the 1932 team came into the season as underdogs but treated "each game as a battle and a test of their own strength and endurance" and won the Mystic Valley Title.
1936
Mystic Valley League Title
7-3
Coach Harold Poole
Captains George Paterson & Joseph Pagnucci
Accused of 3 unlawful acts by the Melrose Log: losing to Malden, tieing Winthrop and the "most serious crime," losing to "turkey day" rivals Arlington, they redeemed themselves by retaining the Mystic Valley Title.
1941
Mystic Valley League Title
10-2
Coach Harold Poole
Captains Carl Rautenburg &
George Bryant
"A fine season" where the Red Raiders won the Mystic Valley League title with a perfect in-league record, beating Malden 19-0 and Wakefield for the 16th time.
1943
Mystic Valley League Title
Undefeated
Coach Dave Gavin
Captain Carlton Ward
The 2nd successive undefeated/untied season and raised to Class A in the State Championship Ratings had, according to the Melrose Log "hipper-dipper and razzle-dazzle plays along with box formation spinners and laterals baffled the opposition 157-7 in points."
1959
Middlesex League Title
Class B State Champions
Coach Joe Hogue
Captain Kenny Palm
After a number of building years, Melrose roared into the 1959 season and finished up undefeated in the recently formed (1957) Middlesex League.